【转】Is Razavi's analog textbook too simple ?

teradyne

The best topics treated in Razavi's book are feedback and noise issues. The book in general is light to read and if you don't understand analog design here, you don't understand anywhere else. Nevertheless, OpAmp design is better treated in Johns & Martin and Gray.
Allen & Holdberg is more like a cookbook (I'm not saying that's bad)

semico_ljj

上述论点看完，赞一个！

semico_ljj

没人参与讨论啊！

semico_ljj

The best topics treated in Razavi's book are feedback and noise issues. 这句不太认同，呵呵
OpAmp design is better treated in Johns & Martin and Gray. 这句很赞成！

semico_ljj

I have read the book again and again.I can find more new knowledge every time.同感!

semico_ljj

I read "Analysis and Design of Analog Integrated Circuits" by Grey. It is also a good book. But for beginner, they may be lost in the large amount of the arithmetic deriving.
好，赞同！

semico_ljj

razavi, allen and gray's are all not for beginners, you can't throw either of them after you read it.
再加个Martin就齐全了！

semico_ljj

Basic conceptual understanding of things like cascodes, regulated cascodes (gain-boost), common-mode feedback and a great deal of small-signal analysis are very useful.

这句说对了！

semico_ljj

But dont forget the MOST important thing: you have to do some real design with CAD!
好！

semico_ljj

1. CMOS Analog Circuit Design (Allen,Holberg)
2. Design of Analog CMOS Inegrated Circuits (Razavi)
3. Analog Integrated Circuits Design (Johns,Martin)
4. Microelectronic circuits (Sedra,Smith)
5. CMOS Circuit Design Layout and Simulation (Baker,Li,Boyce)
6. Analysis and Design of Analog Integrated Circuits (Gray,Hurst)

5所列的书没见到过！